Best show in the city. Open mic or otherwise Poppi is the best fun evevironment for the audience and comics to either work on old material or new stuff just have fun.
Capital: O. Capital: M. Capital: G. This mic is so faaaaaaaabulous! Be prepared to riff with MC (amazing how he can add syllables to monosyllabic words). And be prepared to work your bits in front of a real-life, non-comedic audience!
This open mic is not worth for any straight person. Only perform at this open mic if you're gay. The bar is an open (and very) gay bar. The comics and patrons who show up are gay. And they won't laugh at anyone who isn't. Every person who did a set the night I performed who wasn't gay got SILENCE. Every gay guy who got up there got laughs. It was actually eye opening and sad how rude gay people can be.
The bar had no actual audience members. All were comics. So much so, the host joked about anyone who walked in - who coincidently left very quickly.
I've done stand up several times and got big laughs at material I tried here and heard crickets at The Duplex. I was shocked at the silence as I did my stuff.
I'm not mad, or being spiteful. I'm being honest. This is not supportive unless you're a very outgoing gay guy.
Can't disagree with you more. I'm straight, I think, and I got a couple good laughs the night I went up. There were at least two other "straight guy" performers who got more laughs than I did, because they were funnier than me that night. I didn't detect any overt or covert hostilities towards my sexual identity. Granted, the Duplex is a "gay heavy" spot - no boys I'm not calling you fat - but it's open and supportive to all. Frankly, I find the above observations insecure and mildly homophobic.
This is a good spot. The regular host creates a good vibe & he's funny. If he's on vacation, it can be less good. There are non-comics in the audience. It's also a good deal - just a drink. Both straight and gay are welcome.
I loved this mic and I am a heterosexual woman. Sometimes your shit doesn't hit, you can't blame a general group of people. Everytime I go, there are actual audience members and that is rare for most of these mics.
I am a straight guy and you are a fucking moron. First, that power imbalance must be similar to how most gay comics feel in other spaces. Second, funny is funny.
It is your job (as a comic - though probably a shitty one)to adapt to your surroundings AND connect with the crowd. If you are out of you element - GOOD it pushes you to work harder and find commonalities, it teaches you to diversify.
Any mic in the city has 'mic regulars' who generally get more support, because they regularly support the mic. You are a tool bag - blaming your shittness as a comic and person on it being a gay room.
I just came back from there, I didn't do my bit... I chickened out at the last minute I am regretful now... but I am going to tell you why I left...
In the first place. Every comedian was so good and I am so new in this that I felt overwhelmed.... It felt like a real show and not only an open mic. The set I was going to do suddenly became absolutely lame in my head and I m not ready to adapt my material very fast yet. (I didn't even brought my moleskin... I was so sure of myself and them... OMG)
But I will be back with a better rehearsed set or a more appropriate one.
And then... The host... which is a really funny guy, and I mean it, I am not sure if he is making a living off comedy but he could...
but... I am not sure what the guy from above means with the comment: "Be prepared to riff with MC" It should say: "Be prepared to be interrupted every 10 seconds by a guy that just has to be funnier than you every time" ( and he is sometimes)
Maybe he does that on purpose so you learn how to deal with that sort of thing I really honestly don't know....
One of the comedians was evidently pissed off because he just couldn't finish his sentences...
So I was sure if the guy interrupted me once I was going to black out or something....
In few words:
Should you go? OF COUSRE!
But be prepared!
The crowd is awesome!
I will go back when I get the guts to do it, I am sure this will be a great training and I want to get good enough to the degree of being able to deal with this sort of stuff.... because, you know what? most of the comedians managed very very well, I don't know if they loved it, but they were all super pro...
I don't mean to be mean, That was just my personal experience....
Tony.
P.S. About the only for gay comedians stuff.... I didn't fell any of that.... I agree, funny is funny, gay or straight....
Tony- Though the host of this mic can be over-bearing at times, I feel his overall intention is to have fun at his mic and to have fun with the comedians -of the performing and non-performing type. Ergo, he's working the room. One can either wrap themselves up in their own fears and perceive his "heckling" as exactly that: heckling. Or, like a good musician, one can choose to listen to the ideas being offered and run with them; hence the term "riffing".
This is a good mic. Loads of talent at various levels of "polish". You should come back to this one sooner than later Tony and take the dive!
This is a good/challenging mic. It's true that the host does make comments during your set (he has his own wireless mic) but its a lot of fun regardless. Lots of women & gay guys but i'm straight & i didn't mind because the vibe was fun. My only negative is that the shape of the place is in a triangle & the people who sit in the back tend to not pay much attention as the mic moves along.
Couple things about this mic-Just because you're signed up don't expect to get on. They tell you it's a lottery, but actually the host just picks who we wants to go up. So unless you know the guy, have a reputation as being a funny comic, or are extremely lucky. Don't really expect a shot. About 25 comics sign up, and he picks around 15. And there are at least 15 regulars that have established a rapport there. Hard to argue for it or against it. If the same people go there every week, spend money, and get laughs. Is the host really supposed to tell those comics that they're being bumped for some new guy no one has ever heard of?
The comics were hilarious though. By far the best group I've seen gathered at an open mic. It's a really great environment to work your stuff. If you can get a slot, it's well worth your time. Just don't put all your eggs in that basket expecting to work some stuff, because you probably wont get a chance.
High energy audience that can come crashing down on you if you can't command attention. You know how some comedians repeat the punchline and say stuff like, "I'll let that one sink in for a minute" as if it's the audience's fault for not understanding the joke? Won't happen here. The MC will chime in something fierce if you do so prepare to go along with it. Also, the host might start talking loudly to other people in the back, but its not the frickin' ballet, so I'd just get used to it.
The mic is not first-come first-serve, so I think Badslava should change that, but that doesn't mean it's not a good mic. The host will let new people up granted they are on the top part of the list. Also, you can get away with not ordering a drink if you stay away from the bar. I wouldn't recommend it, you cheap prick, but I will say the drink minimum is not enforced.
Girls! There are actual females here! If you're a lady comic that doesn't want to be stuck in a dark, dirty room with a dozen or so sad-loooking heteros, then get your skankass to Duplex, a homo hotspot. There are straight guys there and guys that say they're straight too, so an overall mixed crowd.
I didn't get to go up, but the experience was such an upgrade from other open mics that I will be returning early to sign up. The experienced comics inspired me and the in-your-face MC with a microphone louder than yours will toughen you. Definitely have some gay jokes too. It is a cabaret bar.
Definitely NOT first come first served. Host has a lot of "friends", granted these friends are talented comics -for the most part- and they do get preferential treatment. Hey, it's the fuckin' guy's mic, what are you going to do? Oh, and be prepared for incessant heckling from the chronic drunk with the second microphone.
HORRIBLE mic for straight comics. Do not go. It's a rip, even at just one drink. The host has the whimsy of infantile leukemia and f**ks with your act. He's a ponce and douche. DO NOT GO TO THIS MIC.
@ "...whimsy of infantile leukemia": The proper wording is INFANT leukemia. By turning the noun into an adjective(infant to infantile) you're now describing leukemia as infantile. For example, it would be wrong to say: "Infantile leukemia refuses to clean it's room, it has a lot of growing up to do." Try instead: "The host has all the charm and wit of a four year old with a terminal case of infant leukemia". If your jokes are anything like your review, one suspects you harbor hostilities towards many mics not just this one. Oh and I've seen plenty of straight comics kill in this room. Time to look in the mirror champ.
Its a fun room, just be prepared to riff. If you just want to go up there and do your set, it probably won't go so well. You're gonna have to engage the audience and the host.
Would be a good mic if it weren't for three things: 1) The host has his own microphone and screws with you/makes his own jokes while you're doing your set. 2) You have to show up an hour or two early to get a spot, and even then you might not get it since people sign their friends up, too, so there isn't much of a chance of getting on the list unless you have nothing better to do. 3)The sign up sheet is supposed to be random, but the host basically puts his friends up first, then randomizes it.
Duplex: This is my first criticism of a comedy club in over a decade of performing stand up, and yes- I am one of the few comics that actually support the bartender heavily. If there were ever such a case of attention deprivation for a so called comedian to try his hand at stand up, this is it. The host literally is dying for attention to the degree that he actually holds a mic in the back the room talking over the comedian as they perform. What’s even worse is the fact that he truly believes he is the first at doing this old trick….it’s been done for decades but since comedy has been making a come back this old hack is trying to reclaim it with the disguise of being “original”. If you wish to enjoy a room of local new comics, enjoy. But if you truly enjoy the art of comedy, please avoid!! The host is disgusting! Just to give you insight with an ego of this host I am pretty sure he will come back with either a retaliation within a few minutes of this post or paying this site to have it removed due to his constant obsession with checking on potential criticisms of himself such as this…dude, when the Broadway career never took off that doesn’t imply to take a go at stand up – respect the stage and get off!!
"But if you truly enjoy the ART of comedy..." Seriously? Only to be followed up with: "Respect the stage and get off." What are you a professor of comedy theory at the Des Moines School of Comedy? Dude: it's an open mic. If you don't like the way it's run, exercise your prerogative and don't show-up. Please spare us the character assaults, they're childish and inaccurate. I've never heard Micheal Bril(host) claim exclusive ownership towards his hosting technique- I've been there more than once. And if you took the time to read the hand-full of the above posts, you'd see the issue is throughly discussed. Some due diligence may have spared you and your precious sensibilities. Finally: this is a good open mic, the energy in the room is usually high and the comics are friendly, especially the host.
I recently performed there (ike avelli) and it was my first time. I have to say, reading some of these posts had me worried as I was traveling from Pennsylvania. The host (Michael) was amazing and treated me as if I was a regular there. I did get to go on last, but was completely worth the trip from PA. Thank you for the opportunity and cannot wait to visit again real soon!!!
I agree! Go to a real comedy club where there are never any hacks and the room is always filled with people who are polite and supportive. Where managers will take you under their wing and nurture your comedy talent and help you grow into the best possible you that YOU CAN BE. So, go! Go with fleet feet and bask in the love and glory of comedy clubs, those Shangri-La's without politics, greed, avarice, exploitation, nepotism, or sexual chicanery. The Duplex open mic is just one more example of how gay men dominate the comedy industry and prevent decent, good christian straight guys a chance at succeeding. They should close this place down.
I go to this mic all the time because it's the best in the city. Like all open mics, it has its clique. Unlike most of the other open mics, however, the Duplex clique is friendly and supportive. They don't all go up first and then leave the room, leaving it empty. The regulars stay and watch and support everyone. Try finding that at another open mic. (You can't.) Now let's talk about the host. Yes, he has a microphone and he uses it. If you are such a delicate flower that you can't roll with some banter from the host, then you should probably quit comedy and become an accountant. If your act is so precious that you can't relax and have fun and be spontaneous every once in a while, then you are missing the point of comedy. And that's where the host does a good job - he keeps the mic fun by *occasionally* chiming in with a quick word for a quick laugh. He doesn't take over your act, the audience loves it, and that's one reason why real audience members actually come to this show. So to all the haters, get over yourselves. And not for nothing, his comments are never mean-spirited, unlike several hipster hosts I know who will trash you when your set is over. As for the demographics, most of the comics are straight and half of them are women. So this notion that the Duplex isn't for straight people is just bizarre.
Lots of regulars go up very, very late as well. It is totally random. And if the host giving banter bothers you, good luck ever doing panel on television.
I've had a great experience actually performing at this mic and I'm a sraight girl. The problem with it is the getting to perform. I've showed up 2 hours before the mic starts and the list is full with most of the names written in the same handwriting. That's bullshit. It's advertised as "first come first served" not "first person with an unemployed friend who can sign you up at 1pm first served." They need to figure out a fair sign up system.
It's the end of the Mic and there are still 25 ppl here.
To the straight guys above... Wah Wah Wah my vagina hurts.
If you come to this mic, bring your funny. I bet Shaun Elijah is one of the detractors above. If you've ever seen him live, you understand what it is like to be in an audience hostage situation!
@ "Half the audience will be dead of aides in a few years"...You must be proud of yourself you inbred imbecile. The correct spelling of the acronym for Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome is: AIDS. Do us all a favor and go back to the double-wide you've crawled out from under and resume your meth habit.
I also said the word faggot, but I didn't think it was that big a deal because I've seen the gay comedians and women comics use the word multiple times there, but apparently my jokes while making half the room laugh seemed to have offended the other half. Also Mike can be a douche, but I'm going to call him out on being a faggot (as in asshole, not homosexual)next time he heckles/makes condescending gay hand gestures.
There is no such thing as parsing the word faggot to mean "asshole." That's like calling a black person a nigger and then saying, "Oh, I don't mean it in the racist way." You are a Louis CK clone idiot who wants all the power of using a homophobic slur without consequence. It's a clever little chestnut, but it isn't possible. You are a hack and bigot. Grow up.
How does it feels to bomb at a open mic when all the other comics killed? WELL, I tried to get up at the Duplex twice already, once it was my first time and I actually got there at 7:00 which is when the show started.. So I wasn’t able to get up, the list was full. Then I came back the next week at 5:00 thinking I’m early.. I was wrong! I was on the waiting list or whatever it’s called. Which sucked but whatever I still had a show that night. But anyways, the thing about this mic is that it SEEMS like everyone are killing up there.. I personally found a couple of very funny comics and was impressed so I figured it’s a great mic. The atmosphere is awesome, usually it’s packed, and the host – I think Michael is pretty cool. SO 3rd week I got there, motivated, ready to do this mic! So I got there at 4:00, when the bar opens.. (ya don’t get there at 3 nobody’s there) and then I went back home because wtf am I gonna do for 3 hours?? I didn’t wanna do other mics and rush or whatever. Which I guess looking back it was possible. But anyways, the regular host wasn’t there, 2 comics hosted instead, they both are very funny, my opinion.. ! and it was fun. The thing is that nobody knows me since I just moved here from Los Angeles, so I’m still walking in the dark.. I guess. So the way they do it is even if you’re second on the list (like I was) it doesn’t mean u going up second.. They chose when to get you up. I got up around 8:00. After I introduced myself.. I got a little discouraged. But got over it. So I went up, first mistake, opened with a new joke. And I don’t know at some point I wanted to say so many words in so little time so everything sounded like a mess.. I think 2 min in I had a joke coming. I think I was so focused on the crowd that I lost focus in my jokes. I got a couple of giggles, which is fine when everybody else get the same, but that wasn’t the case. I almost felt like I had to introduce myself like it was a support group. So I did. My death jokes didn’t go so well, which is alright, it’s a gay bar. Oh and my rape jokes. So yeah I think dark shit ain’t the best jokes to open with :). Sometimes you can really feel when comics judge you. But it’s cool I do it too. Bottom line, it was a good experience. Did I feel great after it? Fuck no I felt like shit but if it doesn’t kill you it makes you stronger. So yeah it wasn’t the best experience for me, but I do think if you become a regular then u’ll get allot of love back, because most of the comics there were very comfortable and weren’t even telling jokes just venting and they still got a good response. SO, fuck yeah I’m going back there, I will say this, I do think when there’s new comics then it’ll be awesome to show some support and put them up early. That’s my opinion :) :) Holla This is my second week in NY from LA. Originally from Israel.. feel free to read my blog http://nycomedybyricki.blogspot.com/ :)
The host is a complete asshole. Because he's gay he feels like he can say whatever he feels like. He is not funny and the mic has a terrible vibe if you're not a regular.
Because he's gay? Are you kidding? It's because he's the host and he doesn't give a shit what a tender little sapling you are. This is comedy. Grow a pair. Oh, and good luck finding a kinder open mic where your spirit is accepted and nurtured. Idiot.
@ "...Because he's gay he feels like he can say whatever he wants..." No, he says whatever he wants because it's his mic. Granted, this mic has some deep flaws, but at least the "regulars" will give you about a minute of their attention to establish your set. If you on top of your shit, and your jokes are funny, YOU WILL GET LAUGHS. If you suck, as we all do from time to time, YOU WILL NOT GET LAUGHS. Isn't that the case with most mics?
I just returned from this open mic as an audience member because I wanted to get a feel for the process before my first go at stand-up. The environment was only supportive and encouraging. When one comic was working out some glitches in her material, the host said something to the effect, "Don't sweat it; that's what this is for." I am very much looking forward to going back next week and giving it my best shot. Great vibe at this place!
it was a very interesting room. Definitely different from doing open mics at a club setting with a stage and lighting. Since you are at a bar, you do feel closer to the audience but it's also slightly more intimidating as well. Some of the regulars had pretty top-notch material that's rare to find in other open mics. 80% of the comics were overtly sexual though. But definitely at a higher level than some other mics.
non-comic bar visitors going in and out of the bar were a blessing and a curse. It was nice that we could have actual audiences but 1)they left early and 2)they talked a lot and made a lot of noise.
the sign-up is filled rapidly by 6PM.
The host does chime in with his comments but I saw no problem with that. He seemed like a nice guy. I would say that this is quite a supportive room with an interesting, unique vibe. Give it a try, although I don't think I will be back anytime soon. It's definitely not your average open mic, I didn't feel ready for this place yet.
Never exclude exceptions from the equations, primary example is being in love with humor, and humor not reciprocate the intuitive obsession, However its feasible to argue the former, that inner intuition might be the rudiments of objective desires, Then an unexplainable desire for humor is a latent biological entailment, and if thats not the case, your intuitive desires are not necessarily conducive to an objective capacity for something, independent to your subjective interpretations.
There is a gaggle of alt-comics that troll this city, and for whatever reason they refuse to laugh at an "outsider's" jokes. Thankfully this mic is free from the afore mentioned clique. My theory is that they're terrified, sniveling, little homophobes.
I agree with the above comment. I've never been to The Duplex but the alt douche bags are the first ones to call someone homophobic or racist for their jokes. They're projecting just a little lol
I completely ate shit at this mic but that's my own fault. Even after bombing hard the host was still very supportive and nice.The talent level here is very high. Wouldn't recommend performing at this mic for people just starting out. You better be confident in yourself and your material. This was definitely the most consistently funny open mic I've ever been too (except for me)... Go check it out.
Wow, the previous reviewers were not kidding about the talent level at this mic. Really top notch, working comedians here. I would have died doing this as a newbie - glad I waited over a year to finally hit this mic! Great times - high energy, supportive room, feels like a real show, with some real audience. Everyone seems to have known each other for years. True that if you are late to sign up and not already a regular, you may not get on. But seems worth it to become a regular here to get the quality stage time and get inspired by all the talent here. NOT true that you have to be gay to do well here. Straight comics were totally crushing it. Funny is funny.
This is the best and most difficult mic in NYC which is why the opinions are so split. I know this room well and attest to the following:
1) The Host - Michael Brill is a grade-A gentleman. He throws out comebacks which can be rough on an insecure comic who's bombing, but he does this to keep up the room's energy level. This is a busy bar during happy hour and his job is to keep the bar patrons there buying drinks. He does this very well and in the end everyone benefits from having real audience there. Michael is no longer there every week and alternates are filling in with varying degrees of success using his modus operandi.
2) The Sign-up - The list goes up at 5pm and the show starts at 7pm. They guarantee (I believe) the first 16 spots, everyone else is put up as time allows. The order of the list is not the order of the show and that's made very clear at the onset. Pro comics show up all the time often get time and are put up early so they can get to other gigs they may have that night. The pros keep the energy level high and yes, it sometimes feels clique-ish but they've paid their dues. There have been rumors about comics slipping bartenders a few bucks to sign them up but I cannot vouch for that. When comics who sign up aren’t given time, which is rare, they’re almost always offered time on a future show to make amends.
3) The Bar - The Duplex is one of the oldest cabarets in NYC. Joan Rivers and Woody Allen started out there at their Grove Street location. It's a cabaret/piano bar on Christopher Street just two doors down from Stonewall so yes, it’s pretty gay. The room is oddly shaped, windows all around, with entrances both at the front and back of room. It's an awkward space, difficult to master. The notion that straight comics bomb there and gays kill is nonsense. The crowds there laugh if you're funny and don't if you're not. They smell B.S. a mile away so if you're unprepared and linger over your notes or blame them when something doesn't work they'll turn on you. If you're really giving it your A-game they're forgiving and supportive.
4) The Talent - this mic has been ongoing for years and many past regulars are now working pros. There's definitely a larger LGBT contingent than other mics but they’re regularly outnumbered by straight comics. One may feel like an outsider at first but it's a very easy group to assimilate to. The comics all generally stick around until the end and it goes noticed and rewarded. When comics dart after their set it’s also noted and factored into future line-ups.
5) Summary - this is not a regular open mic and it's best to watch a couple times before you perform there. You’ll bomb in this room harder than you'll bomb anywhere else but you’ll also kill harder. If you're up for the challenge, you’ll get better faster at the Duplex than anywhere else but it's not for the faint of heart. Do the work and don’t be an a-hole and you’ll do just fine there.
One of the most supportive mics around.
ReplyDeleteAgree. Positive vibe.
ReplyDeleteBest show in the city. Open mic or otherwise Poppi is the best fun evevironment for the audience and comics to either work on old material or new stuff just have fun.
ReplyDeleteAmazing! I love this room!
ReplyDeleteCapital: O. Capital: M. Capital: G. This mic is so faaaaaaaabulous! Be prepared to riff with MC (amazing how he can add syllables to monosyllabic words). And be prepared to work your bits in front of a real-life, non-comedic audience!
ReplyDeleteThis is the best review of this place:
ReplyDeleteThis open mic is not worth for any straight person.
Only perform at this open mic if you're gay. The bar is an open (and very) gay bar. The comics and patrons who show up are gay. And they won't laugh at anyone who isn't. Every person who did a set the night I performed who wasn't gay got SILENCE. Every gay guy who got up there got laughs. It was actually eye opening and sad how rude gay people can be.
The bar had no actual audience members. All were comics. So much so, the host joked about anyone who walked in - who coincidently left very quickly.
I've done stand up several times and got big laughs at material I tried here and heard crickets at The Duplex. I was shocked at the silence as I did my stuff.
I'm not mad, or being spiteful. I'm being honest. This is not supportive unless you're a very outgoing gay guy.
Straight guy comics stay away.
So now you now it feels.
Deleteyeah man, now you now it feels.
DeleteCan't disagree with you more. I'm straight, I think, and I got a couple good laughs the night I went up. There were at least two other "straight guy" performers who got more laughs than I did, because they were funnier than me that night. I didn't detect any overt or covert hostilities towards my sexual identity. Granted, the Duplex is a "gay heavy" spot - no boys I'm not calling you fat - but it's open and supportive to all. Frankly, I find the above observations insecure and mildly homophobic.
ReplyDeleteThis is a good spot. The regular host creates a good vibe & he's funny. If he's on vacation, it can be less good. There are non-comics in the audience. It's also a good deal - just a drink. Both straight and gay are welcome.
ReplyDeleteI loved this mic and I am a heterosexual woman. Sometimes your shit doesn't hit, you can't blame a general group of people. Everytime I go, there are actual audience members and that is rare for most of these mics.
ReplyDelete@"Straight guy comics stay away."
ReplyDeleteI am a straight guy and you are a fucking moron. First, that power imbalance must be similar to how most gay comics feel in other spaces. Second, funny is funny.
It is your job (as a comic - though probably a shitty one)to adapt to your surroundings AND connect with the crowd. If you are out of you element - GOOD it pushes you to work harder and find commonalities, it teaches you to diversify.
Any mic in the city has 'mic regulars' who generally get more support, because they regularly support the mic. You are a tool bag - blaming your shittness as a comic and person on it being a gay room.
I just came back from there, I didn't do my bit... I chickened out at the last minute I am regretful now... but I am going to tell you why I left...
ReplyDeleteIn the first place. Every comedian was so good and I am so new in this that I felt overwhelmed.... It felt like a real show and not only an open mic. The set I was going to do suddenly became absolutely lame in my head and I m not ready to adapt my material very fast yet. (I didn't even brought my moleskin... I was so sure of myself and them... OMG)
But I will be back with a better rehearsed set or a more appropriate one.
And then... The host... which is a really funny guy, and I mean it, I am not sure if he is making a living off comedy but he could...
but... I am not sure what the guy from above means with the comment: "Be prepared to riff with MC" It should say: "Be prepared to be interrupted every 10 seconds by a guy that just has to be funnier than you every time" ( and he is sometimes)
Maybe he does that on purpose so you learn how to deal with that sort of thing I really honestly don't know....
One of the comedians was evidently pissed off because he just couldn't finish his sentences...
So I was sure if the guy interrupted me once I was going to black out or something....
In few words:
Should you go? OF COUSRE!
But be prepared!
The crowd is awesome!
I will go back when I get the guts to do it, I am sure this will be a great training and I want to get good enough to the degree of being able to deal with this sort of stuff.... because, you know what? most of the comedians managed very very well, I don't know if they loved it, but they were all super pro...
I don't mean to be mean, That was just my personal experience....
Tony.
P.S. About the only for gay comedians stuff.... I didn't fell any of that.... I agree, funny is funny, gay or straight....
Tony-
ReplyDeleteThough the host of this mic can be over-bearing at times, I feel his overall intention is to have fun at his mic and to have fun with the comedians -of the performing and non-performing type. Ergo, he's working the room. One can either wrap themselves up in their own fears and perceive his "heckling" as exactly that: heckling. Or, like a good musician, one can choose to listen to the ideas being offered and run with them; hence the term "riffing".
This is a good mic. Loads of talent at various levels of "polish". You should come back to this one sooner than later Tony and take the dive!
Best-
"Be Prepared to Riff..."
This is a good/challenging mic. It's true that the host does make comments during your set (he has his own wireless mic) but its a lot of fun regardless. Lots of women & gay guys but i'm straight & i didn't mind because the vibe was fun. My only negative is that the shape of the place is in a triangle & the people who sit in the back tend to not pay much attention as the mic moves along.
ReplyDeleteCouple things about this mic-Just because you're signed up don't expect to get on. They tell you it's a lottery, but actually the host just picks who we wants to go up. So unless you know the guy, have a reputation as being a funny comic, or are extremely lucky. Don't really expect a shot. About 25 comics sign up, and he picks around 15. And there are at least 15 regulars that have established a rapport there. Hard to argue for it or against it. If the same people go there every week, spend money, and get laughs. Is the host really supposed to tell those comics that they're being bumped for some new guy no one has ever heard of?
ReplyDeleteThe comics were hilarious though. By far the best group I've seen gathered at an open mic. It's a really great environment to work your stuff. If you can get a slot, it's well worth your time. Just don't put all your eggs in that basket expecting to work some stuff, because you probably wont get a chance.
High energy audience that can come crashing down on you if you can't command attention. You know how some comedians repeat the punchline and say stuff like, "I'll let that one sink in for a minute" as if it's the audience's fault for not understanding the joke? Won't happen here. The MC will chime in something fierce if you do so prepare to go along with it. Also, the host might start talking loudly to other people in the back, but its not the frickin' ballet, so I'd just get used to it.
ReplyDeleteThe mic is not first-come first-serve, so I think Badslava should change that, but that doesn't mean it's not a good mic. The host will let new people up granted they are on the top part of the list. Also, you can get away with not ordering a drink if you stay away from the bar. I wouldn't recommend it, you cheap prick, but I will say the drink minimum is not enforced.
Girls! There are actual females here! If you're a lady comic that doesn't want to be stuck in a dark, dirty room with a dozen or so sad-loooking heteros, then get your skankass to Duplex, a homo hotspot. There are straight guys there and guys that say they're straight too, so an overall mixed crowd.
I didn't get to go up, but the experience was such an upgrade from other open mics that I will be returning early to sign up. The experienced comics inspired me and the in-your-face MC with a microphone louder than yours will toughen you. Definitely have some gay jokes too. It is a cabaret bar.
I want to go back... but the thing is " What are the chances I get on? is it really a lottery, so is it not a first come first serve sort of thing?
ReplyDeleteTony V.
Definitely NOT first come first served. Host has a lot of "friends", granted these friends are talented comics -for the most part- and they do get preferential treatment. Hey, it's the fuckin' guy's mic, what are you going to do? Oh, and be prepared for incessant heckling from the chronic drunk with the second microphone.
ReplyDeleteHORRIBLE mic for straight comics. Do not go. It's a rip, even at just one drink. The host has the whimsy of infantile leukemia and f**ks with your act. He's a ponce and douche. DO NOT GO TO THIS MIC.
ReplyDelete@ "...whimsy of infantile leukemia": The proper wording is INFANT leukemia. By turning the noun into an adjective(infant to infantile) you're now describing leukemia as infantile. For example, it would be wrong to say: "Infantile leukemia refuses to clean it's room, it has a lot of growing up to do." Try instead: "The host has all the charm and wit of a four year old with a terminal case of infant leukemia". If your jokes are anything like your review, one suspects you harbor hostilities towards many mics not just this one. Oh and I've seen plenty of straight comics kill in this room. Time to look in the mirror champ.
ReplyDeleteIts a fun room, just be prepared to riff. If you just want to go up there and do your set, it probably won't go so well. You're gonna have to engage the audience and the host.
ReplyDeleteI'm also straight or whatever.
Would be a good mic if it weren't for three things: 1) The host has his own microphone and screws with you/makes his own jokes while you're doing your set. 2) You have to show up an hour or two early to get a spot, and even then you might not get it since people sign their friends up, too, so there isn't much of a chance of getting on the list unless you have nothing better to do. 3)The sign up sheet is supposed to be random, but the host basically puts his friends up first, then randomizes it.
ReplyDeleteMic grade: C-
Duplex: This is my first criticism of a comedy club in over a decade of performing stand up, and yes- I am one of the few comics that actually support the bartender heavily. If there were ever such a case of attention deprivation for a so called comedian to try his hand at stand up, this is it. The host literally is dying for attention to the degree that he actually holds a mic in the back the room talking over the comedian as they perform. What’s even worse is the fact that he truly believes he is the first at doing this old trick….it’s been done for decades but since comedy has been making a come back this old hack is trying to reclaim it with the disguise of being “original”. If you wish to enjoy a room of local new comics, enjoy. But if you truly enjoy the art of comedy, please avoid!! The host is disgusting! Just to give you insight with an ego of this host I am pretty sure he will come back with either a retaliation within a few minutes of this post or paying this site to have it removed due to his constant obsession with checking on potential criticisms of himself such as this…dude, when the Broadway career never took off that doesn’t imply to take a go at stand up – respect the stage and get off!!
ReplyDelete"But if you truly enjoy the ART of comedy..." Seriously? Only to be followed up with: "Respect the stage and get off." What are you a professor of comedy theory at the Des Moines School of Comedy? Dude: it's an open mic. If you don't like the way it's run, exercise your prerogative and don't show-up. Please spare us the character assaults, they're childish and inaccurate. I've never heard Micheal Bril(host) claim exclusive ownership towards his hosting technique- I've been there more than once. And if you took the time to read the hand-full of the above posts, you'd see the issue is throughly discussed. Some due diligence may have spared you and your precious sensibilities. Finally: this is a good open mic, the energy in the room is usually high and the comics are friendly, especially the host.
ReplyDeleteI recently performed there (ike avelli) and it was my first time. I have to say, reading some of these posts had me worried as I was traveling from Pennsylvania. The host (Michael) was amazing and treated me as if I was a regular there. I did get to go on last, but was completely worth the trip from PA. Thank you for the opportunity and cannot wait to visit again real soon!!!
ReplyDeleteDO NOT go to this mic if you are straight or like comedy. Host is a hack. The room is rude and mean. Go instead to a real comedy club.
ReplyDeleteI agree! Go to a real comedy club where there are never any hacks and the room is always filled with people who are polite and supportive. Where managers will take you under their wing and nurture your comedy talent and help you grow into the best possible you that YOU CAN BE. So, go! Go with fleet feet and bask in the love and glory of comedy clubs, those Shangri-La's without politics, greed, avarice, exploitation, nepotism, or sexual chicanery. The Duplex open mic is just one more example of how gay men dominate the comedy industry and prevent decent, good christian straight guys a chance at succeeding. They should close this place down.
DeleteI go to this mic all the time because it's the best in the city. Like all open mics, it has its clique. Unlike most of the other open mics, however, the Duplex clique is friendly and supportive. They don't all go up first and then leave the room, leaving it empty. The regulars stay and watch and support everyone. Try finding that at another open mic. (You can't.) Now let's talk about the host. Yes, he has a microphone and he uses it. If you are such a delicate flower that you can't roll with some banter from the host, then you should probably quit comedy and become an accountant. If your act is so precious that you can't relax and have fun and be spontaneous every once in a while, then you are missing the point of comedy. And that's where the host does a good job - he keeps the mic fun by *occasionally* chiming in with a quick word for a quick laugh. He doesn't take over your act, the audience loves it, and that's one reason why real audience members actually come to this show. So to all the haters, get over yourselves. And not for nothing, his comments are never mean-spirited, unlike several hipster hosts I know who will trash you when your set is over. As for the demographics, most of the comics are straight and half of them are women. So this notion that the Duplex isn't for straight people is just bizarre.
ReplyDeleteLots of regulars go up very, very late as well. It is totally random. And if the host giving banter bothers you, good luck ever doing panel on television.
ReplyDeleteI've had a great experience actually performing at this mic and I'm a sraight girl. The problem with it is the getting to perform. I've showed up 2 hours before the mic starts and the list is full with most of the names written in the same handwriting. That's bullshit. It's advertised as "first come first served" not "first person with an unemployed friend who can sign you up at 1pm first served." They need to figure out a fair sign up system.
ReplyDeleteIt's the end of the Mic and there are still 25 ppl here.
ReplyDeleteTo the straight guys above... Wah Wah Wah my vagina hurts.
If you come to this mic, bring your funny. I bet Shaun Elijah is one of the detractors above. If you've ever seen him live, you understand what it is like to be in an audience hostage situation!
HAHAHA. This is the best post on this thread. +1
DeleteIs this mic all fart swallowers?
ReplyDelete@ "Is this mic all fart swallowers?"...Only when your cheap-whore-momma shows up and works the glory-hole.
ReplyDeleteDon't be mad if you don't get laughs in this room. Half the audience will be dead from aides in a few years
ReplyDeleteThis is an apology: I did not know that this was a gay place when I said the dreaded "f*gg*t" word. I am sorry.
ReplyDelete@ "Half the audience will be dead of aides in a few years"...You must be proud of yourself you inbred imbecile. The correct spelling of the acronym for Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome is: AIDS. Do us all a favor and go back to the double-wide you've crawled out from under and resume your meth habit.
ReplyDeleteDon't forget your fly swatter to deal with the fruit flys.
ReplyDeleteI also said the word faggot, but I didn't think it was that big a deal because I've seen the gay comedians and women comics use the word multiple times there, but apparently my jokes while making half the room laugh seemed to have offended the other half. Also Mike can be a douche, but I'm going to call him out on being a faggot (as in asshole, not homosexual)next time he heckles/makes condescending gay hand gestures.
ReplyDeleteThere is no such thing as parsing the word faggot to mean "asshole." That's like calling a black person a nigger and then saying, "Oh, I don't mean it in the racist way." You are a Louis CK clone idiot who wants all the power of using a homophobic slur without consequence. It's a clever little chestnut, but it isn't possible. You are a hack and bigot. Grow up.
DeleteThis host Is SO S-A-A-A-A-D!!!!!!!
ReplyDelete"double-wide... meth habit?" Aw-w-w-w-w!!!! Is somebody angry?
DeleteHow does it feels to bomb at a open mic when all the other comics killed?
ReplyDeleteWELL, I tried to get up at the Duplex twice already, once it was my first time and I actually got there at 7:00 which is when the show started.. So I wasn’t able to get up, the list was full. Then I came back the next week at 5:00 thinking I’m early.. I was wrong! I was on the waiting list or whatever it’s called. Which sucked but whatever I still had a show that night. But anyways, the thing about this mic is that it SEEMS like everyone are killing up there.. I personally found a couple of very funny comics and was impressed so I figured it’s a great mic. The atmosphere is awesome, usually it’s packed, and the host – I think Michael is pretty cool. SO 3rd week I got there, motivated, ready to do this mic! So I got there at 4:00, when the bar opens.. (ya don’t get there at 3 nobody’s there) and then I went back home because wtf am I gonna do for 3 hours?? I didn’t wanna do other mics and rush or whatever. Which I guess looking back it was possible. But anyways, the regular host wasn’t there, 2 comics hosted instead, they both are very funny, my opinion.. ! and it was fun. The thing is that nobody knows me since I just moved here from Los Angeles, so I’m still walking in the dark.. I guess. So the way they do it is even if you’re second on the list (like I was) it doesn’t mean u going up second.. They chose when to get you up. I got up around 8:00. After I introduced myself.. I got a little discouraged. But got over it.
So I went up, first mistake, opened with a new joke. And I don’t know at some point I wanted to say so many words in so little time so everything sounded like a mess.. I think 2 min in I had a joke coming. I think I was so focused on the crowd that I lost focus in my jokes. I got a couple of giggles, which is fine when everybody else get the same, but that wasn’t the case. I almost felt like I had to introduce myself like it was a support group. So I did. My death jokes didn’t go so well, which is alright, it’s a gay bar. Oh and my rape jokes. So yeah I think dark shit ain’t the best jokes to open with :). Sometimes you can really feel when comics judge you. But it’s cool I do it too. Bottom line, it was a good experience. Did I feel great after it? Fuck no I felt like shit but if it doesn’t kill you it makes you stronger.
So yeah it wasn’t the best experience for me, but I do think if you become a regular then u’ll get allot of love back, because most of the comics there were very comfortable and weren’t even telling jokes just venting and they still got a good response. SO, fuck yeah I’m going back there, I will say this, I do think when there’s new comics then it’ll be awesome to show some support and put them up early. That’s my opinion :) :)
Holla
This is my second week in NY from LA. Originally from Israel.. feel free to read my blog
http://nycomedybyricki.blogspot.com/
:)
So its safe to say if I get there at around 6ish I won't be able to.go up?
ReplyDeleteThe host is a complete asshole. Because he's gay he feels like he can say whatever he feels like. He is not funny and the mic has a terrible vibe if you're not a regular.
ReplyDeleteBecause he's gay? Are you kidding? It's because he's the host and he doesn't give a shit what a tender little sapling you are. This is comedy. Grow a pair. Oh, and good luck finding a kinder open mic where your spirit is accepted and nurtured. Idiot.
Delete@ "...Because he's gay he feels like he can say whatever he wants..." No, he says whatever he wants because it's his mic. Granted, this mic has some deep flaws, but at least the "regulars" will give you about a minute of their attention to establish your set. If you on top of your shit, and your jokes are funny, YOU WILL GET LAUGHS. If you suck, as we all do from time to time, YOU WILL NOT GET LAUGHS. Isn't that the case with most mics?
ReplyDeleteI just returned from this open mic as an audience member because I wanted to get a feel for the process before my first go at stand-up. The environment was only supportive and encouraging. When one comic was working out some glitches in her material, the host said something to the effect, "Don't sweat it; that's what this is for." I am very much looking forward to going back next week and giving it my best shot. Great vibe at this place!
ReplyDeleteOne of the best open mics in the city.
ReplyDeleteit was a very interesting room. Definitely different from doing open mics at a club setting with a stage and lighting. Since you are at a bar, you do feel closer to the audience but it's also slightly more intimidating as well. Some of the regulars had pretty top-notch material that's rare to find in other open mics. 80% of the comics were overtly sexual though. But definitely at a higher level than some other mics.
ReplyDeletenon-comic bar visitors going in and out of the bar were a blessing and a curse. It was nice that we could have actual audiences but 1)they left early and 2)they talked a lot and made a lot of noise.
the sign-up is filled rapidly by 6PM.
The host does chime in with his comments but I saw no problem with that. He seemed like a nice guy. I would say that this is quite a supportive room with an interesting, unique vibe. Give it a try, although I don't think I will be back anytime soon. It's definitely not your average open mic, I didn't feel ready for this place yet.
They should call this the open ass mic.
ReplyDeleteHosts who put friends up first are douchebags - mics are for comics to work stuff out.
ReplyDeleteNever exclude exceptions from the equations, primary example is being in love with humor, and humor not reciprocate the intuitive obsession, However its feasible to argue the former, that inner intuition might be the rudiments of objective desires, Then an unexplainable desire for humor is a latent biological entailment, and if thats not the case, your intuitive desires are not necessarily conducive to an objective capacity for something, independent to your subjective interpretations.
ReplyDeleteMagnificent Place
Atelston Fitzgerald Holder 1st
@ "Hosts who put up their friends first are douchebags" So, what are you saying? Every open mic host in the city is a douche? Get over it skippy.
ReplyDeleteYour logic is flawed and therefore your post is useless and lame.
DeleteThere is a gaggle of alt-comics that troll this city, and for whatever reason they refuse to laugh at an "outsider's" jokes. Thankfully this mic is free from the afore mentioned clique. My theory is that they're terrified, sniveling, little homophobes.
ReplyDeleteI agree with the above comment. I've never been to The Duplex but the alt douche bags are the first ones to call someone homophobic or racist for their jokes. They're projecting just a little lol
ReplyDeleteSign up for this begins at 5 and fills up fast. Just learned this the hard way...
ReplyDeleteHost riffs on other people's jokes... that's like stealing... and it's rude... ass clown.
ReplyDelete@ "Host riffs on other people's jokes..."
ReplyDeleteSo riffing on the previous comic's jokes at a mic, or a show for that matter, makes one a rude thief?
"Ass clown"?
I'm afraid your comments betray your inexperience as a comic and hack-tendencies as a person.
This is a fantastic open mic: It's challenging, energetic and attended by really good comics (host included)
I completely ate shit at this mic but that's my own fault. Even after bombing hard the host was still very supportive and nice.The talent level here is very high. Wouldn't recommend performing at this mic for people just starting out. You better be confident in yourself and your material. This was definitely the most consistently funny open mic I've ever been too (except for me)... Go check it out.
ReplyDeleteLove this Mic. Love this room. Love the regulars. Love Michael Brill (the host). "It's Show business, people!"
ReplyDeleteWow, the previous reviewers were not kidding about the talent level at this mic. Really top notch, working comedians here. I would have died doing this as a newbie - glad I waited over a year to finally hit this mic! Great times - high energy, supportive room, feels like a real show, with some real audience. Everyone seems to have known each other for years. True that if you are late to sign up and not already a regular, you may not get on. But seems worth it to become a regular here to get the quality stage time and get inspired by all the talent here. NOT true that you have to be gay to do well here. Straight comics were totally crushing it. Funny is funny.
ReplyDeleteThis is the best and most difficult mic in NYC which is why the opinions are so split. I know this room well and attest to the following:
ReplyDelete1) The Host - Michael Brill is a grade-A gentleman. He throws out comebacks which can be rough on an insecure comic who's bombing, but he does this to keep up the room's energy level. This is a busy bar during happy hour and his job is to keep the bar patrons there buying drinks. He does this very well and in the end everyone benefits from having real audience there. Michael is no longer there every week and alternates are filling in with varying degrees of success using his modus operandi.
2) The Sign-up - The list goes up at 5pm and the show starts at 7pm. They guarantee (I believe) the first 16 spots, everyone else is put up as time allows. The order of the list is not the order of the show and that's made very clear at the onset. Pro comics show up all the time often get time and are put up early so they can get to other gigs they may have that night. The pros keep the energy level high and yes, it sometimes feels clique-ish but they've paid their dues. There have been rumors about comics slipping bartenders a few bucks to sign them up but I cannot vouch for that. When comics who sign up aren’t given time, which is rare, they’re almost always offered time on a future show to make amends.
3) The Bar - The Duplex is one of the oldest cabarets in NYC. Joan Rivers and Woody Allen started out there at their Grove Street location. It's a cabaret/piano bar on Christopher Street just two doors down from Stonewall so yes, it’s pretty gay. The room is oddly shaped, windows all around, with entrances both at the front and back of room. It's an awkward space, difficult to master. The notion that straight comics bomb there and gays kill is nonsense. The crowds there laugh if you're funny and don't if you're not. They smell B.S. a mile away so if you're unprepared and linger over your notes or blame them when something doesn't work they'll turn on you. If you're really giving it your A-game they're forgiving and supportive.
4) The Talent - this mic has been ongoing for years and many past regulars are now working pros. There's definitely a larger LGBT contingent than other mics but they’re regularly outnumbered by straight comics. One may feel like an outsider at first but it's a very easy group to assimilate to. The comics all generally stick around until the end and it goes noticed and rewarded. When comics dart after their set it’s also noted and factored into future line-ups.
5) Summary - this is not a regular open mic and it's best to watch a couple times before you perform there. You’ll bomb in this room harder than you'll bomb anywhere else but you’ll also kill harder. If you're up for the challenge, you’ll get better faster at the Duplex than anywhere else but it's not for the faint of heart. Do the work and don’t be an a-hole and you’ll do just fine there.